The Secret Society of Monster Friends has been nominated for the Nordic Council Children and Young People’s Literature Prize 2024 and the Reykjavik Children’s Literature Prize for the best illustrations 2024. The book tells the story of Stefanía and Pétur, friends who encounter everyday challenges through imaginative adventures, and introduces a new classmate, Jóhann Steinn, whose arrival stirs tension.

The Nordic Council’s nomination praises the book for its “simple and well-executed narrative,” noting its unique portrayal of childhood without moralizing, focusing instead on the blend of everyday life with imagination. “The authors have a unique way of highlighting all the insignificant and even fantastic things that characterize childhood,” states the Council’s rationale.

Illustrator Sólrún Ylfa’s work is also recognized for its vibrant and humorous style, which enhances the text with “simplicity and numerous details,” making the story more engaging for young readers.

A particular scene exemplifies the book’s approach: Stefanía and Pétur find mysterious black powder and consult the local ‘witch,’ a figure who diverges from traditional portrayals. This narrative choice highlights a child’s perspective on what adults recognize as mold—a common societal issue in Iceland—turning a serious adult concern into a captivating children’s adventure.

Character development is another strong point, with Stefanía portrayed as a proactive and strong role model, while Pétur is more cautious, showcasing a dynamic that helps readers develop a moral compass indirectly. The book facilitates conversations about friendship, inclusion, and the impact of decisions in daily life without overshadowing the sense of adventure.

These nominations underscore the book’s appeal to children and adults alike, recognizing its contribution to contemporary children’s literature by engaging young imaginations and addressing real-life issues through storytelling.